mel

The first agent to reply usually gets the client

Here’s how to be that agent without living on your phone.

· 5 min read

It’s 6:40 on a Tuesday evening. A buyer fills out the contact form on your website. They want to see a house this week.

You’re having dinner with your family, phone face-down on the counter. You see the inquiry at 7 the next morning and reply right away.

By then, the buyer has already booked a showing with another agent, the one who texted back last night.

Nobody did anything wrong. But the lead went to whoever answered first. The answer isn’t being on call every evening. It’s having something that replies for you.

Many clients hire the first agent they talk to

Many buyers and sellers stop looking once they find an agent who responds.

  • 47%of buyers hired the first agent they spoke with
  • 59%of sellers did the same

Source: Zillow’s 2025 Consumer Housing Trends Report for Agents

The first good conversation often decides who gets the client. A lead who doesn’t hear back from you is very likely talking to someone who did reply.

Most inquiries still go unanswered

You’d expect fast replies to be the norm. They aren’t. In October 2026, Pied Piper tested 2,198 phone and website inquiries to local offices of 21 large real estate brands.

  • 68%of website inquiries got no response within 24 hours
  • 33%of callers reached an agent on the first call
  • 1 in 10website inquiry forms didn’t work properly

Source: Pied Piper’s 2026 Real Estate Lead Handling Effectiveness Study, as reported by Real Estate News

The same study found:

  • 73% of callers got no follow-up within 24 hours.
  • Only 10% of website inquiries heard from an agent within an hour.

Mike DelPrete found something similar in 2024. In more than 100 secret-shopper inquiries across more than 25 brokerages, nearly half of the online inquiries got no response at all. The average reply took 8 hours and 17 minutes, and the median was 39 minutes, all during weekday business hours.

If you reply within minutes, you’re already ahead of most of the market.

Your warmest leads need speed too

Speed isn’t only about strangers filling out forms.

  • 43%of buyers found their agent through a referral
  • 18%used an agent they had worked with before

Source: NAR’s 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers

Those leads look like:

  • A past client texting to ask what their home might sell for
  • A friend passing your name to a coworker who’s starting to look

They’re the warmest leads you have, and a slow reply wastes them. A referral who waits two days may decide you’re too busy and call the other name they were given.

Why replies are slow (it isn’t laziness)

Agents reply late because they’re working. Leads don’t wait for a quiet moment. They arrive while you’re:

  • At a showing, a closing, or an inspection
  • In the middle of a walkthrough
  • At dinner with your family

How people want to hear back matters too. In Zillow’s 2025 report, 50% of buyers who used an agent prefer texting or messaging apps, and only 33% preferred phone calls. A short text is often the most welcome first reply, and it’s the hardest one to send from a showing.

How Mel replies to every lead within minutes

Back to that Tuesday evening. The buyer fills out your form at 6:40 p.m. Within minutes, Mel texts them back in your voice and offers a few times to see the house. When the buyer is ready, Mel books the showing and lets you know. You finish dinner.

  1. New website inquiry
    Contact form · Nora EllisCan I see 14 Birch Lane this week?
  2. Mel texts back
    Hi Nora, thanks for reaching out! I can show you 14 Birch Lane Thursday at 5:30 or Saturday at 11. Which works?
    Sent by Mel
  3. Showing booked
    SAT11Saturday, 11:00 am14 Birch Lane · Nora Ellis
    Added to your calendar, and Mel lets you know.
An evening inquiry, answered by Mel within a minute and booked before dinner is over. Illustrative example.

Mel handles every part of fast follow-up for you:

  • The first reply. Mel reaches out to every new lead within minutes, by text, in your voice.
  • The back-and-forth. Mel answers questions, suggests homes, and offers times to meet.
  • The follow-up. Mel keeps leads engaged with personalized updates over weeks and months, so no lead is forgotten.
  • Every lead source. Your website, your sphere, open house sign-ins, and any list you add.
  • The handoff. When a lead is ready, Mel books it on your calendar and tells you. Want to see messages first? Approve them before they go out.

Sources

Get your invite to Mel.

Mel is invite only. Join the waitlist to apply for early access.

Join the waitlistAlready have an invite code? Click here.